After watching Scott Pilgrim vs. The World two and a half times, I feel like I’ve seen it enough to be able to accurately express my opinions on it.
First, I love the movie. Love it. So much. Despite this, there are some things that I really don’t like about it, but we’ll get to those eventually.
First, the things that are awesome.
1. It’s medium-bending. I love that it’s a combination of movie, video game, graphic novel, and whatever the fuck else that comes into play. It doesn’t take itself seriously as any of these things, and it’s great. I should really read the graphic novels someday, but that’s neither here nor there.
2. Hipsters, hipsters, hipsters. And then some more hipsters for good measure. God, I love hipsters. Seriously though, extremely relevant to my interests.
3. Nerd things. All the nerd things. Again, relevant to my interests.
4. Ridiculous hair. I do love me some crazy hair. If I’m being honest with myself, Ramona’s turquoise hair inspired me to dye my hair turquoise. Yes, I’m influenced by pop culture sometimes, shocking.
5. Michael Cera. He’s so awkward and wonderful. People give him shit for it, but no, he’s great.
6. Ramona Flowers is adorable.
7. It’s not often that I find myself identifying with female characters, but I could identify (at least to a certain extent) with most of the female characters. It was kind of refreshing.
Now, for the things I didn’t like.
1. Regardless of anything else, this movie has the same essential plot as every other romantic comedy ever. It’s done really well, but it’s still the typical plotline. Boy is scarred. Girl is scarred. Boy finds girl, falls immediately in love. Girl is unsure. Boy fights for girl. Girl is still unsure. Boy follows girl. They ride off into the sunset. I know that’s really simplified, and I’m ignoring some things, but you can’t deny that it’s a romantic comedy. Hipster romantic comedy, but still romantic comedy. Now, that’s fine, but not necessarily my cup of tea. I would have loved for them to not end up together, but that’s life; people don’t watch romantic comedies for the main characters to end up alone.
2. Ramona is essentially defined by her relationship to men, and her hair. Actually, now that I think about it, most of the female characters are defined by their relationships to men, and their hair. I understand that that’s the point, but I’m still not totally comfortable with that. Yes, they have other defining characteristics, but also no, no they don’t.
Don’t get me wrong, I love this movie, and I didn’t feel the same sense of cynicism that I usually feel after watching a romantic comedy, but I still felt a nagging sense that although this movie tried to be different from the typical rom coms, it essentially ended up being the same. I know that most people will probably disagree with my negative opinions, but what can I say, liberal arts education.